Introduction

The nature of God’s love and hatred has been a subject of profound theological exploration throughout Christian history. In contemporary Christian discourse, God’s love is often portrayed as unconditional, while His wrath is sometimes downplayed. However, a thorough examination of Scripture reveals that God’s love and hatred are not opposing concepts but are integral aspects of His character, reflecting both His grace and His justice. This study seeks to explore the biblical, historical, and doctrinal dimensions of God’s love and hatred, providing a well-rounded understanding for Bible students.

Chapter 1: The Biblical Basis for God’s Love and Hatred

1.1 The Love of God

The Bible makes it clear that God’s love is both foundational and sacrificial. John 3:16 famously states, “For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.” This passage highlights that God’s love is not limited to a select few but is universally available to all people. God’s love is action-oriented, demonstrated through His sacrifice of His Son for the salvation of the world.

This love is not a mere sentimental affection but a deliberate and purposeful act of grace. Romans 5:8 further clarifies this, saying, “But God commendeth his love toward us, in that, while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us.” God’s love is expressed in the willingness to sacrifice for the benefit of humanity, even when humanity is in rebellion against Him. While God’s love is offered universally, its full benefits are received only through faith in Christ.

A crucial aspect of God’s love is that it is conditional in the sense that it demands a response. The love that God offers is not automatic, nor does it force itself upon anyone. In passages like John 3:16, we see that God’s love extends to all but its power to save is conditioned upon the individual’s response of faith. This universal love and the necessity of human response is a key theme throughout Scripture.

1.2 The Hatred of God

While God’s love is readily acknowledged, the Bible also speaks plainly about God’s hatred, especially regarding sin and rebellion. Psalm 5:5 states, “The foolish shall not stand in thy sight: thou hatest all workers of iniquity.” This verse points to the reality that God’s holiness requires a righteous response to sin, and His hatred is directed not merely toward sin in an abstract way but toward those who actively engage in sin and refuse to repent.

Proverbs 6:16-19 provides a specific list of things that God hates, including “a proud look, a lying tongue, and hands that shed innocent blood.” These are not merely negative traits but actions and attitudes that reflect rebellion against God’s moral order. God’s hatred is thus not arbitrary but is rooted in His holiness and justice. God’s wrath is a necessary response to human sin, especially when individuals persist in sin and refuse to turn toward Him.

God’s hatred is also a reflection of His justice. In a world where moral evil exists, God must respond. This aspect of God’s character underscores His righteousness, which cannot coexist with evil. The concept of God’s hatred should not be viewed as a capricious emotion but as a justified, holy response to that which is in direct opposition to His nature.

Chapter 2: Historical and Theological Perspectives

2.1 The Early Church Fathers on Divine Love and Wrath

The early Church Fathers grappled with the relationship between God’s love and His justice. Figures such as Irenaeus and Origen emphasized the goodness of God and His universal desire for the salvation of all humanity. Origen, in particular, is often cited for his belief in the eventual reconciliation of all things, suggesting that God’s love extends to all, even those who initially reject Him.

John Wesley, the founder of the Methodist movement, argued that God’s love is universally extended to all people, and His justice demands that individuals be held accountable for their choices. In his writings, Wesley emphasized that God’s wrath is experienced by those who reject His grace, but this is not a result of an arbitrary predestination. Rather, human beings have the free will to accept or reject God’s offer of salvation.

Wesley’s thoughts reflect a belief in God’s love as both conditional and universal. His emphasis on human free will aligns with the non-Calvinist understanding that while God offers His love to all, individuals must freely choose to accept it in order to experience the fullness of His grace.

2.2 The Reformation and the Nature of Divine Wrath

During the Reformation, the discussion about divine justice became central. Reformers like Martin Luther and John Calvin emphasized the absolute holiness of God and the necessity of justice in salvation. However, in non-Calvinist thought, there was a clear distinction made between God’s love and the justice required by His holiness.

In contrast to Calvin’s doctrine of predestination, which asserts that God’s love is limited to the elect, non-Calvinists affirm that God’s love is universal, extended to all people regardless of their fate. For non-Calvinists, God’s justice is satisfied through the atonement of Christ, which is available to all who respond to the gospel. This understanding highlights that while God’s justice requires punishment for sin, His love made provision for all to be reconciled to Him through faith in Christ.

2.3 John Wesley and the Nature of Divine Judgment

John Wesley believed that God’s judgment is inseparable from His justice but also that it operates in accordance with human free will. Wesley wrote, “But as for the wicked, God hates them, and will feverishly punish them” (Explanatory Notes Upon the Old Testament, Vol.2, p.1639). For Wesley, divine judgment was not an arbitrary decree but a response to human choices.

Wesley saw God’s judgment as just and based on the individual’s rejection of God’s grace. Unlike the Calvinist understanding, where God’s wrath is predetermined for the reprobate, Wesley emphasized that divine judgment is conditional upon how individuals respond to the gospel.

Chapter 3: Theological Implications of God’s Hatred

3.1 The Fall of Man and Divine Wrath

The Fall of man in Genesis 3 marks the moment when human sin brought a breach in the relationship between God and humanity. This break was not simply a theological abstraction but had real consequences: death, alienation from God, and the necessity of redemption. Romans 6:23 confirms this reality, stating, “For the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.”

God’s wrath is not a reflection of an arbitrary decision but a natural response to sin. His justice demands that sin be punished, but His love provides the way for redemption. While humanity is fallen and subject to the consequences of sin, God’s wrath is not aimed at individuals in a capricious manner; it is a reflection of His righteous anger against sin and injustice.

3.2 The Cross as the Reconciliation of Love and Hatred

At the cross, the full weight of God’s love and justice are on display. Jesus Christ, in His sacrificial death, bore the punishment for sin, satisfying the justice of God while making a way for reconciliation with humanity. 2 Corinthians 5:21 states, “For he hath made him to be sin for us, who knew no sin; that we might be made the righteousness of God in him.”

The cross is where God’s love and hatred meet. God’s hatred of sin is poured out upon Jesus, who bears the penalty for humanity’s sin. At the same time, God’s love is revealed in the fact that Jesus willingly took this punishment on behalf of those who believe. Through Christ’s atonement, God’s love is extended to all who respond in faith, and His wrath is satisfied.

Chapter 4: The Judgment of the Wicked

4.1 Eternal Judgment in Scripture

The Bible consistently affirms the reality of eternal judgment. Revelation 21:8 speaks of the ultimate fate of the wicked: “But the fearful, and unbelieving, and the abominable, and murderers, and whoremongers, and sorcerers, and idolaters, and all liars, shall have their part in the lake which burneth with fire and brimstone.” This is the final expression of God’s wrath upon sin and rebellion.

God’s judgment is not arbitrary but based on a person’s response to His grace. Those who choose to reject God’s offer of salvation experience eternal separation from Him. This judgment is a necessary result of the free will choices that individuals make in this life.

4.2 The Second Death

The “second death” described in Revelation 20:14 is the eternal separation from God, often interpreted as spiritual death. This second death is not a temporary state but an eternal one, signifying the ultimate consequence of rejecting God’s offer of grace. It highlights the seriousness of human choices and the eternal consequences that come with those choices.

4.3 The Role of Free Will and Divine Justice

Non-Calvinist theology emphasizes the centrality of human free will in salvation and judgment. While God’s justice is absolute, it operates in conjunction with human choice. God’s wrath is not a predetermined punishment for individuals, but a response to their rejection of His love. God’s justice demands that sin be punished, but that punishment is applied to those who freely choose to reject God’s grace.

Chapter 5: Practical Implications

5.1 Evangelism and the Fear of God

Understanding both God’s love and His wrath shapes the Christian approach to evangelism. Jude 1:23 instructs, “And others save with fear, pulling them out of the fire.” This passage reminds us that the reality of eternal judgment should motivate believers to share the gospel with urgency, calling others to repentance and faith in Christ.

5.2 The Christian Life and Holiness

The Christian life is marked by a response to God’s love. Believers are called to reflect God’s holiness in their own lives, actively pursuing righteousness. 1 Peter 1:16 states, “Be ye holy; for I am holy.” As recipients of God’s love, Christians are called to live lives that reflect God’s character, rejecting sin and embracing holiness.

5.3 The Role of the Church in Preaching Both Love and Wrath

The church is tasked with teaching the full counsel of God. This includes proclaiming both God’s love for humanity and His righteous judgment upon sin. A balanced approach ensures that believers understand the seriousness of sin, the need for repentance, and the incredible offer of salvation through Jesus Christ.

Conclusion

The Bible reveals a complex but coherent picture of God’s love and hatred. Both aspects of God’s character are necessary for understanding His justice and grace. God’s love is universal and freely offered to all, while His wrath is a necessary consequence of sin. This study shows that God’s love and hatred are not contradictory but complementary, and they provide the foundation for understanding His work in salvation and judgment. By grasping these truths, Bible students can develop a deeper appreciation of God’s holiness, justice, and mercy.

---

This study provides a detailed, non-Calvinist view on the biblical doctrines of God’s love and hatred, emphasizing the importance of human free will and the necessity of a response to God’s grace.